1. Home
  2. Health
  3. AIDS / HIV

Readers Respond: Should HIV Disclosure Be Mandatory?
Responses: 6

By , About.com Guide

User responses are not monitored by About.com's Medical Review Board.

Since the emergence of the HIV epidemic, the call for HIV disclosure has been around. And with that call for total disclosure comes controversy. Some feel disclosure is an absolute necessity to maintain the public health. Others feel it is a private matter and forcing disclosure would be a breach of confidentiality. What do you think? What Do You Think and Why

Mandatory HIV Disclosure

The rights and health of everybody should be considered, if an HIV+ person is going to have sex with a partner, he/she has an obligation to disclosure to that would be partner, there are cases where HIV+ are more concerned protecting their privacy than the health and well being of their partners....so YES, they should disclose.
—Guest evergreen

The Scarlet Letter

forcing disclosure of one's HIV status is akin to sewing a scarlet 'A' on all their clothing and shunning them as much as possible. There are not enough HIV education programs available - especially in rural areas - to adequately inform the general population what is true and what has been imagined by those that saw but were not affected by the huge numbers of deaths when HIV and AIDS reared their ugly heads. The only thing that will remove the stigma of individuals living with HIV/AIDS is teaching as many people as possible the facts about the disease. It is not 1984 any more. We know how to treat this, and HIV+ are living longer and having a normal life.
—Guest tjc1204

mandatory disclosure

yes status shiuld be disclosed because no one should be allowed to determine when or how you die
—Guest calloway

Shared confidentiality

In view of psycho-social changes involved with HIV test results,a client who tests positive will most probably decline to disclose their positive status even to their spouses..therefore there's need to protect the spouse(in a legal marriage or cohabitation)by sharing the status with them and consequently having them test theirs too especially in the Kenyan society.
—Guest Felix Munene University of Nairobi

mandatory disclosure

IDON'T THINK IT SHOULD BE UNLESS YOU ARE PLANNING TO HAVE SEX WITH THA PERSON
—Guest lorna henry

mandatory HIV disclosure

for couples / intending couples. for casual affairs,hiv + person mus guard against infecting his / her partner.
—Guest ibrahim rasheed

What Do You Think and Why

Should HIV Disclosure Be Mandatory?

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

Explore AIDS / HIV
About.com Special Features

Learn how you can reduce your your numbers with these nutrition and exercise tips. More >

Keep yourself, and your family, happy and healthy this fall with these tips. More >

We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health information: verify here.
  1. Home
  2. Health
  3. AIDS / HIV
  4. Testing & Prevention
  5. AIDS Activism
  6. Public Health - HIV Disclosure - HIV and Public Health - HIV Dislosure>

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.